Ah yes I was on the receiving end of a critical response process. It was nice because it was well structured and with a clear goal, being "designed to leave the maker eager and motivated to get back to work". You do need clear questions - I didn't really so I didn't get loads out of it at the time.
I think it's a great idea to focus on "artist as a questioner". I already felt commenting on the 'challenge' thread earlier that I wasn't sure whether the recipient actually wanted feedback.. Sometimes it's nice to just share something, for what it is..